[waltjp]

FED is asking (requiring?) the use of a throat protector. How strictly that's enforced in your area is up to your state or local association. I see it as a personal matter.

It could be that they're just covering their behinds in the event of an umpire getting injured and looking to file a lawsuit. If you get hurt and you're not wearing the equipment they suggest or require then you're going to have a hard time holding them responsible.

Shin guards are required but I've worked with someone who didn't wear them. (Don't ask.) I know people who don't wear a cup or plate shoes.

If you’re allowed that level of flexibility in what you decide to wear and are willing to take the risks associated with foregoing certain items of protective equipment that's your choice.