Quote:
|
Originally Posted by CelticNHBlue
I grew up in ASA but have emersed myself in the NCAA signals for the past few seasons. I typically use my NCAA 'hammer' for everything unless my tournament UIC specifically requests that we use the ASA signals. We do not have any formal HS training here, mostly ASA umpires applying the NFCA rules, so I can't speak to their signals/mechanics.
My opinion, ASA developed signals and mechanics that are simple and can be broken down into steps as trained in their schools and clinics because they have to be able to teach anybody how to look like an umpire. The NCAA, at the national level, umpires being evaluated for post-season and D-I assignments, requires a more 'professional' signal. I like the look of the NCAA 'hammer' and I think it looks stronger than the ASA signal, but I agree with Mike that some people can be too aggressive with it.
|
Other than the aggressiveness, I don't like it because it's partially hidden from the players and spectators. Remember, the signals are not there for an "umpire showcase" or the participants in the immediate vicinity. The signals are communication tools and bringing the arm forward in front of the body screens many in the stands and is not always easy for the outfielders to observe.
As far as the "professional" comment, I don't buy it. Just because the highest level of paid umpires use a specific signal doesn't make their mechanics any more professional than that of the rookie umpire doing youth ball. For that matter, MLB umpires are some of the least professional looking/acting umpires I've observed the last few years.
JMHO