[QUOTE]Originally posted by Dakota
I don't think "proper" training or coaching will address the safety issue. I have seen too many teams that have been coached to block the base to believe that.
My sense of "justice" (as opposed to my good sense, maybe) would like to see a distinction made between "set up" obstruction (i.e. the defensive player positions herself in the way) v. "flow of the play" obstruction (e.g. a defensive player runs into the runner). I'd like to see the penalty for the former be given some teeth - e.g. an extra base award. That would go a long way to eliminate base blocking, IMO.
Dakota,
I haven't had any trouble with F3 trying to block the BR advancing to first from home. Usually, that comes into play when the catcher tries to pick off the runner at first. If F3 knows how to set up properly on the edge of 1st, the BR has a clear path, while F3 is protected from contact.
The double base really doesn't help the collision factor on errant throws. But you might be onto something with a penalty with some teeth - umpire judgement never gets questioned anyway!!
|