[AtlUmpSteve]

Wade, what you are saying is a RECENT NCAA mechanic version of 3 man; it isn't what has been taught by ASA NUS.

Truthfully, 1) I feel very uncomfortable being that close to 2nd base, 2) I disagree that the more likely play based on number of incidents is steal over force out, and 3) I disagree that it is easier to back up on a play where you have to wait until the ball is hit and fielded (to make any judgment about the likely play), than it is to step up into a steal that you can see coming from the time the pitcher releases the ball.

But, when doing NCAA, and in evaluation situations, that is what I do; despite the discomfort of knowing I am too close to see the whole play. I do agree with your assessment that Dave should have worked around to more angle to the throw, rather than holding his calling position.