[wadeintothem]

Yep, thats correct and I agree 100%.

I already tried to explain to them with their incorrect interpretation of this rule, they are not only disadvantaging the offense and rewarding for CO, but also creating a situation where a catcher may Intentionally CO or argue that they did CO or dance around pretending the bat hit their glove to try to draw CO.

Kinda odd, but despite their inability to provide any type of written support for their opinon whatsoever, and written evidence presented to the contrary, they still maintain you call the ball dead immediately, even on a hit, homerun, or anything else, whether you advantage defense for the violation or not...