Quote:
Originally posted by mick
Quote:
Originally posted by blindzebra
Forget the ball.
Forget the player control.
B1 had legal guarding position.
A1 knocked him down.
Watcha got?
mick
|
By that logic, A1 goes up for a shot, B1 swings down to block the shot and the force of the blocked shot...without verticality, and no direct contact...knocks A1 down, foul on B1?
|
That's pretty silly.
Did B1 do something wrong?
In the original case, A1 made illegal contact.
In you case there was no illegal contact.
Where's the foul?
mick [/QUOTE]
A1 made contact with
THE BALL in the original play, that is no different than my play.
No contact/no foul, ugly does not equal automatic whistle.