[wadeintothem]

My knee jerk response..
B3 did abandon her turn at plate and PUs brain fart not withstanding...

I got b3 out for abandoning her turn at bat / new pitch was made to new batter afterwards, B4 at bat with 1-0 count.

------------------------------------

after digging around and specifically researching AltUmps BOO ruling.. i muddied the water for myself..

I only have my ASA2004 book.. 2005 ran away or something.. anyway in ASA 2004 .. it says 7-2-1

If BOO is discovered while the incorrect batter is at bat, the correct b atter must take the batters position and legally assume balls and strikes..

---------- It would seem to me that if you as PU play the BOO card, you get a "do over"..

Interesting case play.. I'll read others responses, i know in a game today i would have just called the batter out as that was my initial response here

---------------------------------

Hey its not our fault, all softball players look alike.