Quote:
Originally posted by bob jenkins
This thread reminds me of the similar, much discussed, play: R1, off on the pitch. BR flies to right. F1 realizes that there might be a chance to "double up" R1, so F1 moves to back up the expected throw from F9 to F3. While crossing the foul line, F1 gets in the way of BR. The fly ball is caught. Place the runners.
NAPBL (and probably other OBR sources) have specific language that the obstruction is ignored. IMO, that logic should be applied to FED as well.
|
Bob,
The PBUC Manual treats Batter/Runner obstructed before reaching 1st base in section 4.30. I wouldn't characterize the recommended mechanic as "ignoring" the obstruction. Nor does the reason for F1 obstructing enter into consideration.
PBUC says "
..if the batter runner is obstructed before reaching first base on a fly ball or line drive that is caught, the B/R is out. The reasoning here is that the obstruction had no bearing on the fact that the batter hit a fly ball that was caught by the defense. Similarly, should the B/R be obstructed before reaching first base on a foul ball not caught, the foul ball prevails. Again, the reasoning is that the obstruction had nothing to do with the fact that the runner hit a foul ball."
It then considers three cases: ground ball to an infielder, pop fly or line drive to an infielder, and
"
Case 3: B/R is obstructed before reaching 1st base on a ball hit to the outfield. Ruling: Call the obstruction by pointing at the obstruction and yelling "that's obstruction"; however, leave the ball in play until all action has ceased. Then call "time" and impose such penalties, if any, that will nullify the act of obstruction. If a fly ball is caught in this situation, batter-runner is out...."
IMO, this logic and mechanic can't be applied to FED rules, given FED's automatic award of at least one base.