Mark,
Wow, I thought I was the only one crazy enough to have a "sudden death" overtime in basketball.
I was doing a boys H.S. Varsity Tournament this summer when my partner and I really screwed up. We had 3 O.T's
Finally the game management came over and stated they were on somewhat of a time restraint...we needed to get this game over.
So we came up with your "Sudden death" scenario.
We had the players line up for the jump and away we went.
It was great...the game hinged on every shot. We even had a guy go to the line and miss the front end of a 1 and 1 that would have ended the game.
We all got a kick out of it, even the coaches, something I would highly recommend for your Rec League Mark.
Dan