[PeteBooth]

IMO, Papa C touched on a good topic that could have generated some good and value added discussion especially in the offseason when he talked about Fair and Good. It's too bad it didn't receive more constructive attention instead of what transpired, but that's life in the internet Forums.

I will take it a step further and ask a question that might seem silly but exactly

What is a good umpire?

It's been said that it is harder to make it to the BIGS as an umpire than a Player.

In addition, when comparing umpires, It's not like we are comparing Joe Smo to AROD where there are statistics to back up ones point of view.

1. Is it Hard work and dedication

2. "good ole boy network"

3. Kiss up to the coaches

4. Willingness to travel

4. Luck

Exactly what is a good umpire?

I can't speak for College and the PROS but at the HS level more often than not it's not the best or good umpires that get the Playoff assignments but those that are ALWAYS available and "suck-up"

In a nutshell my opinion of a good umpire is one who is willing to (1) Learn (2) Hustle on the field (3) is not a "Homer" and could't care less who the participants are or coaches.

Ok let's see if we can generate some good solid discussion on exactly what is a good umpire.

IMO, in your responses it would be beneficial if you could site some actual experiences in which to share and help others.

Pete Booth