Well i look at it this way:
When a batter hits a HR he is awarded 4 bases. If, let's say, that batter misses 3rd base and the 3rd base coach grabs him, and directs him backwards to retouch the base, we have an out, don't we?
I think the situation Carl gives us is no different.
My answer is C.
BobJenkins also has a very good answer.
|