No problem jicecone, I don't have all the J/R's, or any of Carl's BRD's to reference. The Jaska/Roder, and other similar interpretation manuals, are only opinions on the rules. They are not hard and fast rules, they are guidelines to go by. There may be 237 errors in the OBR, but that's the book we get to go by, here in lowly amatuer land.
Steve