View Single Post
  #6 (permalink)  
Old Fri Nov 02, 2001, 02:48pm
devilsadvocate devilsadvocate is offline
Official Forum Member
 
Join Date: Sep 2001
Posts: 55
Re: to grab or trip...

Quote:
Originally posted by Rog

[/B]To "grab" or "trip" intentionally is more than "obstruction"; since, they most definitely are "Unsportsmanlike Conduct" rule violations![/B]
So we're on the same track. Obviously, the defense has an advantage if they are allowed to intentionally grab, hold, tackle, trip, etc., the offensive player.

The next question: What rule applies in the above situation? Does anyone know of any casebook example similar to the situation described above?

Rog, assume it's not obstruction, but you judge it to be unsportsmanlike. You could disqualify and then eject the player. That takes care of the player. How do you then handle the play? F6 catches the throw with his left hand (has possession of the ball), then F6 grabs and holds the runner with his right hand, then F6 applies the tag. So what you have to this point is one out. Do you allow the out to stand?
__________________
advocatus diaboli Somebody who criticizes or opposes something in order to provoke a discussion or argument.

Reply With Quote