[bluehair]

[QUOTE]Originally posted by David Emerling
3) If challenged, I'd just tell the offensive manager that the "out" for his batter's desertion is recorded after all continuous action has ended. The defense should not be burdened with sorting out the complex ramifications of the batter's desertion.

This way you don't have to admit that you failed to observe something and the manager will certainly not be able to challenge the "accuracy" of your ruling since he will have no ready reference to challenge you ... not even a rulebook!

I like this explanation much better than my sloppy one. I'd rather make this argument than immediately calling BR out when entering the dugout and picking up the shi#y end of the stick by removing the force.

Good thread folks.