Quote:
Originally posted by Jurassic Referee
Quote:
Originally posted by joseph2493
1) A2 touched it but it ended one try and began another...
2) A2 can touch the ball, but how can you allow the second shot to count
OK: Let's say we do count the goal...do we count it as two (2) points as in Rule 5 Sec 2 Art 1...?
|
1)Completely wrong. A legal touch by any player does not end a try. Rule 4-41-4. There never was a second try.
2)By rule, there is NO second shot. The first shot never ended as per R4-41-4.
3) Yes, if the touching by the teammate was inside the arc. If the touching by a teammate was outside the arc, it's a 3. Case book play 5.2.1SitC spells out the different scenarios.
Joseph, the language in R6-7NOTE is straightforward. It applies directly to elecref's original question. Your answer was wrong.
|
So, looks like another irrational iconsistency here...
A1 shoots a 3, A2 touches it inside the arc...it counts as a two. It seems like this means A2's touch is the start of a new shot. If not, why is it not a 3?