|
Just finished going through the new case book. Do you guys have these plays as being incorrect? I've noted what I think they should be. Comments?
p. 19 *3.3.3 Situation A: In this case, even if B accepts the foul, A is not entitled to an untimed down, per the new 2005 rule change.
p. 19 *3.3.3 Situation B: "... if necessary for playoff qualifying." is wrong - the period must be extended if the penalty is accepted. (per 3-3-3a)
p. 23 *3.5.2 Situation B: (d) is not consistent with prior interpretation that allows an assigned coach (following a disqualification of the head coach) to request a time out.
p. 26 *3.7 Comment - in (a), this is a live ball foul, simultaneous with the snap
p. 30 4.2.2 Situation G: the "Also, momentum is not a factor once the kick touched the ground." statement is now incorrect with the 2005 rule change (per 8-5-2a exception).
p. 34 *5.1.2 Situation B: the penalty is enforced from the basic spot, not the previous spot. This is a live ball illegal participation foul on B12 (per 9-6-4a)
p. 53 *7.5.9 Situation: There is also a foul on A1 for an illegal forward pass (2nd forward pass during the down per 7-5-2e)
p. 55 8.2.2 Situation B: This is a try and the ball should be dead when possession is gained by B. The acceptance of the holding penalty on A10 results in a safety and one point for B.
p. 86 10.4.5 Situation C: Per 9-6-4a (new in 2005) it is illegal participation when any player, replaced player, or substitute enters during the down. This is a live ball, basic spot foul which would be enforced from the end of A1's run (A's 44 yard line), thus giving A a 1st down on B's 41.
Agree or disagree with any of these?
__________________
kentref
|