[Jim S]

In the Seattle assocition we use a peer evealuation. But at the pre-game each coach is given a card with the crew's names, and a 1 to 5 rating for each position with space for comments.
These cards are not used for ratings purposes, but are used to determine if there are consistant problems.
We do a bit of rating on the teams. We give a scholarship award to the team(s) that get reccomended by the membership for exceptional sportsmanship.