Quote:
Originally posted by Jurassic Referee
Quote:
|
Originally posted by Dan_ref
|
What if the player attempts to dunk the ball in his opponent's basket?
BI?
Or nuthin'? [/B]
|
You have a warped l'il mind, Slappy.
The rule EXCEPTION of R4-6 can't apply because it's not a try- therefore it ain't a dunk attempt.
Ergo, if the player tries to dunk it in his opponent's basket, it should be BI as per R4-6-2 and the opponent gets 2 points. It doesn't have to be a try to be penalized- as pointed out in case book play 9.11.2SitC.
What if..... an opponent tried to block that un-dunk attempt at his own basket and both player's hands then entered the cylinder at the same time while contacting the ball?
Double violation- AP? [/B][/QUOTE]
I don't care about the exception, I already have "a player has his/her hand legally in contact with the ball, it is not a violation if such contact with the ball continues after it enters a basket cylinder..."
A player had his/her hand on the ball when it legally entered the cylinder. Why BI?
/edit: I forgot to mention BI does NOT require a try anyway/
btw I was thinking more in terms of the player slamming the ball off the back of his opponent's rim. 2 points for his opponent? Or nuthin'?
Or this: B1 jumps and grabs A1's air ball after it passes over the cylinder. B1's momentum carries the ball back over the cylinder and he lands.
BI and 2 points for A?