Quote:
Originally posted by debeau
That is right .
Also remember the other part of the obs rule .
The runner is awarded the base they would have reached had they not been obstructed .
Hence protected between 1st and 2nd but on a close play at third also safe (Also safe had the gone home and tagged sliding into home)
There is still a penalty against the defensive team and for "Softballmom" she can promote aggressive base running .
As we know aggressive base running puts pressure on the defense ( and Umps) and can win games .
|
Completely disagree. The fact that a play is close at a particular base is not an indicator that the runner should ALWAYS be awarded that base.
Speaking ASA, you determine what would have happened based on the play during which the obstruction occured. If obstructed rounding first on a batted ball to RF, the umpire should get a feel how far that runner would possibly advance on the play. The umpire can take into consideration a misplay on the ball by the fielder involved in THAT play.
However, once determined, it should not be adjusted based on any subsequent action on that play.
To continue the play above, as the umpire I determine that the OBS runner would only attain 2B. As the OBS runner safely strolls into 2B ahead of the throw, I drop the OBS call. However, that throw gets away from F6 and now the previously OBS runner decides to make a dash for 3B. As the umpire, I do NOT extend the obstruction call based on the subsequent play. If the runner makes it, fine. If not, the out will stand.
On another note, after I decide 2B is that to which I'll protect the OBS runner and now the RF lets the ball go by him/her, I can and probably will adjust my protection as this is part of the initial play.
One other thing to mention, unless the runner is put out between the bases where s/he was obstructed, you can never place a runner back to the last base touched.