Quote:
Originally posted by brumey1107
Hello - Im hoping for some input and understanding of my obligation as an umpire to answering a question from a coach regarding a close play.
Sitch: Pony baseball (15 - 16 yo) OBR. I'm doing game solo from behind the plate.
R1 and R3, one out. R1 steals. Catchers throw sails 12 - 15 feet to right of 2 base. F4 catches the throw and lunges for R1. I'm up 1st baseline 5' or so and I call safe.
Off. coach comes out asking (doesn't ask for time) from a distance where the tag was.
So my question is; how much of an obligation do we have as umpires to explain our calls?
Thank you for your opinions.
|
My first comment would have been, "Coach, there was no tag, thats why I called hime safe."
At the begining of EVERY game, I tell the coaches, "I will be glad to answer any question you may have, if you kindly wait until I call Time." I make the same offer when officiating Ice Hockey also.
I don't believe we have ANY obligation to explain our call, however I will state to the coach what is it I saw after he has stated his case, give him a few more seconds to have the final say, (that always builds their ego up), and then let him know the game will now proceed. This may require a little more discussion if there is an interpretation to explain but regardless, I explain to him that we are moving on with the game.
Getting a little respect, sometimes means giving a little. Presenting an "I know it all", "Don't talk to me", "I am above you" arrogance, does nothing more than challange the coach to a duel. Realize one thing, you have the final say. Flaunting your power will not get you as far as you may think. Using it wisely, will.