View Single Post
  #1 (permalink)  
Old Tue Apr 19, 2005, 08:33am
Base Base is offline
Official Forum Member
 
Join Date: Dec 2004
Posts: 25
NCAA rules games

1-10 from A-40: QB throws ball, which would be incompleted, but middle linebacker places his foot so, that ball doesn´t hit the ground, but his foot. There is no doubt, that movement of linebacker´s foot was intentional (it wasn´t accidental contact of ball and foot), but there was no "kicking movement" - linebacker just positioned his foot so, that ball hit it, he didn´t "swing" his leg.
After this, he or another Team B player catches the ball, which never hit the ground and runs into Team A´s endzone.
Legal (Team B´s touchdown) or Illegal (1-10 from B-45)?


1-10 from A-10: QB drops 5y back and towards the sideline. Linebacker follows him and first contacted him on 5y line and drives QB to 3y, where QB is loose again (contact is maintanted but QB is clearly able to run by himself. He isn´t driven or pushed back) and runs into endzone, where (from -1y) he throws the ball forward (towards opponent´s endzone), while running so, that he faces his own endline and the movement of arm is not above the shoulder (nor Jake Plummer style) - he just wants to escape from sack a throws the ball away. Ball hits the ground on 5y where is recovered by another Team B player (who is still on his feet) and he returns the ball into Team A´s endzone. Is it
a) sack (and referee didn´t blow the whistle, where forward progress has finished)
b) safety (because of intentinonal grounding from the EZ)
c) touchdown (because throwing the ball in such way is not passing, but fumble)
d) anything else?

In case a) should be ruled, consider the situation again without the contact between QB and LB and just rule the forward pass/fumble
Reply With Quote