[PeteBooth]

Originally posted by vtjack [/i]

When you're working youth leagues you are teaching everyone, not just the hitter. Specifically, you're also teaching the pitcher that he doesn't have to get the ball over the plate. Do you really think that's a good idea? Not me. An umpire who calls strikes out of the true (rulebook-defined) strike zone is interfering with the balance of the game by helping pitchers who can't find the zone. You're not letting them play their game, you're actively affecting the outcome by not following the rules.

In some youth leagues one is lucky enough if a kid can reach the plate let alone get it in the strike zone.

Rules were written for players that have certain abilities.
When the rule-makers defined the strike zone I'm certain that they didn't have 9/10 yr. old "rugrats" in mind.

The OBR rules as written are for the professional athlete. Yes kids have to learn the rules, but it is gradual. If your going to have a league that allows kids 9/10 yrs. old to pitch, then you need a broader definition of the strike zone otherwise you will still be playing.

Most youth leagues that I know of do in fact have a broader defintion of the zone at that age. Also, no-one likes a walk-a-thon.

Now if you umpire an advanced league (Probably travel) where individuals have to try out and make the team and the talent level is strong, then one doesn't have to taint the zone as much.

Also, do not have a postage for a zone

Pete Booth