[LDUB]

Originally posted by Rich Ives
Are you basing your point on Carl's rant? Maybe I'm reading his rant incorrectly, but here's how I see it:

Carl's rant is about Website #10 saying a faked or feinted throw is a play while 8.3.4h says a feint is not a throw. His recommendation is to ignore Website #10 and use casebook 8.3.4h.


HOWEVER

The question at hand is not about a faked or feinted throw, it is about whether the physical movement by F6 toward R2 constitutes a play. The issue is thus the movement, not a faked or feinted throw. This then comes under the "Website 2003, #7" (not the #10 in the rant) interp that says that a fielder with the ball walking a few steps toward a runner does constitute a play. As such, the wild throw to F3 is a second play under the FED interp.

My bad. Change my vote to a play for FED.