That's what I thought. Even when faced with the "rule/ruling word for word," you still deny that you're wrong. Not surprising.
It matters not how the player got on the floor. The fact is that he is there.
If you would truly only rule this specific situation as written and not similiar situations, then you must treat every play in the case book that way. And that is certainly not the intent of the case book.
BTW, the same people that write the rule book, write the case book. Most case plays have been in the book for years and years. All you have to do is to compare the latest edition to a 10 or 15 year old version. Some of been added but others remain unchanged.
Good night.
|