Sun Jan 16, 2005, 03:25pm
|
|
Official Forum Member
|
|
Join Date: Dec 2003
Posts: 2,674
|
|
Quote:
Originally posted by footlocker
Quote:
Originally posted by blindzebra
Quote:
Originally posted by ref18
Today at my games, my partner and I were discussing this one, after it happened in the NCAA game, and although I said that the basket shouldn't have counted, he said that continuous motion applies. Well anyways, long story short, in the NCAA game, does the basket count, or did the offcials kick this one??
|
NCAA does not have lag time, so if the whistle occurs before the horn time is put back on the clock AND the horn has no baring on the try.
NF: Foul, whistle, horn, release, made basket = no basket and 2 or 3 free throws.
NCAA: Foul, whistle, horn, release, made basket = good shot and 1 FT.
|
ok. Now this stopped making sense for me. Your NF: Foul, whistle, horn, release, made basket = no basket and 2 or 3 free throws.
Why wouldn't the whistle stop the clock here. If I have knowledge in a HS game that this was the order, wouldn't I have the responsibility to put something back on the clock since I know the whistle came before time expired? Thereby having the effect of counting the shot.
btw, no time was put on the clock in the indiana/purdue game.
|
No unless more than a second came off between whistle and horn and the official had definite knowledge, in this case that would mean seeing the clock go from plus one second to zero after the whistle.
NF has lag time, so whistle and horn happening very close together is NOT a timer's error.
|