Quote:
Originally posted by Mark T. DeNucci, Sr.
Quote:
Originally posted by Jurassic Referee
Quote:
|
Originally posted by Mark T. DeNucci, Sr.
|
You just cannot have a block and charge involving the same two players. The rules do not allow it.
|
The rules do not allow it?
Lah me, Mark, you've come up with some real dandies over the years, but this one tops them all.
NFHS Rule 4-19-7 and NFHS Case book play 4.19.7SitC
'Nuff said!
And the sad part is that you are very aware of those plainly written rules!
Lah me! [/B]
|
I know what the Casebook says, and this is an example where the person(s) that came up with that ruling were not wearing their thinking caps. By rule, there cannot be a BLARGE. It is impossible because the defender either had a LGP or he didn't. Maybe it is time for someone to bring it to the Rules Committee's attention.
MTD, Sr. [/B][/QUOTE]
Mark,
A1 is dribbling with B1 attempting to get LGP but does not get there. The only contact is A1's forearm pushing B1, by what you JUST SAID, all we could call was a block on B1 because they did not have LGP.
You can have two players committing illegal contact against each other, and two different officials both seeing half of it.
WOW, about MTD being right and the casebook being wrong. These would be the same ones you held up as correct, when they blatantly mis-applied a rule, in the officials' error/timer's error thread. I guess their word is only golden when it agrees with you.
