Quote:
Originally posted by BktBallRef
Quote:
Originally posted by blindzebra
Quote:
Originally posted by BktBallRef
Quote:
Originally posted by blindzebra
A1 jumps to shoot and is fouled by B1, A1 never releases the ball and returns to the floor, are you going to shoot 2 with the lane cleared and award B the ball on the travel?
|
That's not a violation. The BI is a violation.
|
Take it further, A1 jumps, gets fouled,lands then releases the try and it goes in, are you going to count it?
|
That has nothing to do with ther original plays.
Quote:
|
The question asked was the difference between the penalties on a foul on A2 versus a violation on A2 and that difference is the ball becomes dead on the violation, but not the foul.
|
No, that's not the difference. What causes the ball to become dead has nothing to do with the issue.
NVref's question is what is the rationale for the ball not being awarded to Team B after the FTs in play 1? Neither of your explanations answer that question.
|
You still did not answer the question.
Yes, the ball becoming dead on the violation DOES answer the question. The foul did not cause the try to end, the violation did, THAT IS THE PENALTY when you have a foul against the shooting team and then a VIOLATION by the shooting team. The foul, which did not end the try, carries it's own penalty, thus the cleared lane.