|
we must continue to agree to disagree.....
Mark,
I respectfully disagree with your assesment of the governing rule.
The fact that by rule the timer started the clock as a Timer is supposed to...ie when the official chopped it in, is the governing rule in my opinion.
There is no disputing that the official erred, and how to correct it certainly is up to several debates...
My original opinion however remains unchanged, the timer started the clock by rule, you can not dispute that fact Mark, it is in the rule book that the timer shall start it when an official chops it in. Timers are not to judge whether or not an official chopped it correctly. It is certainly cool if they do, but by rule if they start it on the chop they did it correctly from their standpoint. If you agree with that opinion (and I know Mark doesn't), then you have an officials error that is not correctable...however ivoking 2-3 is certainly a decent thing to do.
[Edited by cmathews on Dec 18th, 2004 at 12:28 AM]
|