Quote:
Originally posted by Dan_ref
Quote:
Originally posted by MJT
Quote:
Originally posted by Dan_ref
Quote:
Originally posted by BktBallRef
Quote:
Originally posted by Dan_ref
Maybe some of us reserve judgement until the play's completed...
|
Judgment was made when the whistle blew.
|
Maybe, which is why I'm wondering if the whistle could have been held to make a more informed judgement.
Watching the Uconn/IU game?
|
This makes no sense. If a player if fouled as he starts a jump, you would wait and see if he passes it or shoots it and then blow the whistle for the foul that occured seconds earlier. These young men can jump pretty darn high and stay in the air a long time. When you "definitely" see a foul, you blow your whistle and then continuing action gives you the result of the play.
I am not a "newbee", the whistle was NOT early! I played the game, have watched the game, and officiated the game, and have yet to see this exact play unfold the way it did.
Let's change it around a little. What if a player goes into the air with what you feel is the intent to pass the ball. You call a foul, so he then decides to shoot the ball. It hits the rim, but doesn't go in. Are you going to give him the ball OOB's in that case?
|
OK, have it your way then. You're not a newbie. It was a great call, maybe the greatest ever. Nothing like this has ever happened before in the entire history of basketball.
Whatever. And keep tootin' that whistle just as fast as you can! You wouldn't want someone to think you missed one.
|
Ok, I'm done with this discussion. I was defending my point, and you yours, we both had good points. I miss a few every game, did so last night on a ball that went OOB's. I have no problem admitting when I do, but as soon as you turn what has been a good debate into a smart--- session I will not go back and forth anymore.
I do appreciate all the discussion, it is how we learn and improve, but I bow out when it gets personal. If you did not intend it that way, then I apologize. Thanks again!