Quote:
Originally posted by JRutledge
Why do these statement make you cringe?
Peace
|
Because they aren't right. I understand the desire to teach newer officials or fans by using clever sayings. However, clever sayings can lead to an incorrect ruling on the field. MOST of the time, the axiom is true. It is those cases where the axiom isn't true that concern me.
The ground can indeed cause a fumble, the kicking team can advance a muff under certain conditions, and we don't always penalize the offense where it hurts them the most. If someone relies upon the axiom rather than understanding the rules behind the axiom, it is bound to lead to an incorrect ruling. My desire for writing such an article is to help people understand the rule behind the axiom.
"Cringe" is a strong word. Maybe I should say, "Shake my head".