Quote:
Originally posted by Carl Childress
Quote:
Originally posted by His High Holiness
Quote:
Originally posted by Carl Childress
I am amazed -- again -- that nobody actually reads my posts.
Show me where I'm on record as "fer" or "agin" Mr. Hopkins' ruling. Smitty -- Smitty's --it ain't there.
"Alls I said" was: "lodged" means "stuck," and the play I put into the BRD in 1994 represents what their rule means -- in English.
It's kind of funny that nobody anywhere knows what I think about the ruling. What's more, you aren't going to know. When I feel a ruling is magnificiently bad and not supproted by logic, I generally say so -- in the BRD.
|
Carl;
Your statement above is inaccurate. Over a week ago, I wrote that you were a reporter, not an interpreter, and that you had reported the facts. Specifically, I closed out the post with the following quote:
"All that being said, I don't recall Carl taking a position one way or another as to whether he thinks the ruling is good for baseball. Unless Tim Stevens surprises us, Carl was reporting the facts and he got them right.
Peter"
So when you say that "nobody actually reads" your posts, you have exaggerated by at least one! 
Peter
|
Peter: I apologize. I knew it was one of my enemies who pointed out I hadn't opined my opinion. I just guessed it was Garth, not Darth.
|
1. In this thread's cousin, "ball stuck in glove",I restated your position that you had not made a ruling.
2. Enemies? A bit melodramtic. I know of no one who considers you an "enemy", Carl. Not Peter, not me, not even Freix.