Quote:
Originally posted by Mark T. DeNucci, Sr.
If B6 had punched A1, then I would have two separate fouls, a technical foul against Team B for too many players on the court and one for the flagrant foul by B6 for punching A1.
[/B]
|
1) Read Bob Jenkins's post to Snags just above your post. He says the samething I am saying, you cannot have two technical fouls in this situation. Please site me a situation where you have charged B6 with a technical foul for illegally entering the game when the first infraction of the rules you discovered was that Team B had six players on the court.
2)Are you telling me that when you discovered a team playing with six players that you charged the team with a technical foul for having six players on the court and the sixth player with a technical foul for illegally entering the court?
[/B][/QUOTE]1) Bob is saying the same thing that you are saying?
Read your own post from before above where you say that YOU would call 2 T's in a similar situation. What's the difference between B6 coming off the bench to steal the ball from A1, or B6 coming off of the bench and fouling(punch-whatever) A1. You're telling me that if B6 had stolen the ball without fouling, there can't be a 2nd. T called- but if B6 had fouled A1 while trying to steal the ball, you can call a second T? That doesn't seem too logical to me.
2) Yup, I'm telling you that- if the player came off of the bench the same as in this sitch. Can you cite any rule or a case book play that states that I can't? I can't think of one, but I've got an open mind.