Re: Thank you for the insight and truth
[QUOTE]Originally posted by WindyCityBlue
From Jeff Rutledge's original post-
I will stay completely out of this discussion and just throw this out there.
Does that mean insert replies four (4) times to the very question at issue?
We see a movement afoot that makes officials more accountable. Umpires are overruling calls in MLB, the Big Ten will allow it in football this Fall, instant replay has been fairly effective in the NFL and NHL recently.
[QUOTE]Just can't let it go with Jeff, can you, Windy? Does it bother you that much that you can't call him names over on McGriffs any more, since Gary put the IP's back in?
Now let's set everything straight here. Not your version of history.
YOU stated that a basketball official could OVERRULE another basketball official.
I stated that the NFHS and NCAA basketball rules very specifically do NOT allow any official to OVERRULE another official. I cited those rules. NFHS rule 2-6 is an example. Officials can give information to other officials, but only the official that made the call can change it. If you want to continue arguing that that is wrong, please cite something from the rules that will back you up.
I await your rules citations.
Btw, see if you can find anything that says JUDGEMENT calls can be changed in Big 10 football this fall too, under the new experimental review process.
|