Thread: Balk or not
View Single Post
  #13 (permalink)  
Old Tue Jun 29, 2004, 06:45am
jicecone jicecone is offline
Official Forum Member
 
Join Date: Apr 2001
Posts: 2,716
Quote:
Originally posted by nine01c
Quote:
Quote:
Then he called a balk on a RH with R1 & R3. The RH stepped & faked to 3rd and then wheeled and threw to 1st. He told the pitcher he had to "disengage from the rubber in order to throw to first!"
He's correct here, at least under OBR. That said, I've never seen F1 make this move without disengaging during the feint to third.
He may not be correct under OBR, depending on how F1 moves. See Rule 8.05c comment following. As long as he steps toward 3B (foot comes down on ground), he can then turn and step toward and throw to 1B legally. The key is he must also make that step toward 1B and not just wheel (spin) and throw. He does NOT have to disengage. He does NOT have to disengage. This is gaining on the Baseball Myth list of all time favorites.
In OBR and NCAA he does have to disengage after his fake to third. He does have to disengage. Federation(HS) rules , he does not.
Reply With Quote