Problem-he was not in his role as an umpire, but as a reporter. It wouldn't be considered an ethical violation. I know, I shouldn't be defending this guy's actions, as it does digust me that he used his "smokescreen" as a reporter to criticize another umpire, but he still does have rights in other positions. However, we umpires know that we shouldn't and don't criticize each other within the brotherhood. This is a touchy situation. I'll be curious how it is handled.