[GarthB]

This topic has long been divided by one simple issue. Did the NCAA crew's call fit within the list of calls referenced by Carl (Two calls by two umpires, each with jurisdiction)

One side, apparently including the umpires on the responsible NCAA crew, believes it does.

The other side, primarily those identifying themselves with something known as EWS, do not.

Fine. Twenty more exchanges is not going to change anyone's opinion.

Let's move on.

GB