Quote:
Originally posted by WindyCityBlue
A runner can be hindered without being able to advance to the next base. This is obstruction -- if it happened between the plate and first in a FED game, leave him at first. If it happened after the BR touched first, award second. It doesn't matter in FED whether he got would've gotten there or not. The fielder doesn't get free reign to get in the way of or bump the runner.
Rich,
Did I miss something? You are going to keep a guy at first if he is obstruvted before reaching that base???
The guy hits a rope down the line and gets tangled with the catcher. The hit would obviously be a double or more. Are you still going to keep him at first.
In Fed it absolutely matters (Umpire Judgement) if he would have gotten there or not. You penalize those that cheat, are stupid or make your job impossible.
|
All I was doing was referring to the original play in the original post. You are the one generalizing the situation.
And yes, I would punish this obstruction every time, jicecone. How do you have contact without hindrance? You aren't judging that he would've made second absent the obstruction at this point, you are only judging that the runner was obstructed.
--Rich