Quote:
Originally posted by Peter Devana
Yes we should have had the count but after the whisle blew and I found out the reason I had honestly forgotten exactly what count I had and I didn't want to guess! Maybe you are right; however, what I did seemed the fairest way to go at the time,regardless, we sold it and noone got upset-C'est la vie.
|
I find it odd that you said, "I would be interested in all opinions and a case answer if there is one," yet you seemed to dismiss what I said without much consideration.
So let's examine it a little closer. The clock operator made one mistake and you compounded it by making two more. You lost track of the count and you penalized A by making them bring the ball from the baseline again. Whether you sold it or not, or thought it was the fairest way to handle it, the fact remains that three mistakes is far worse than one or two.
If you don't agree, that's fine. But you did ask all opinions.