Quote:
Originally posted by wizard
Here's my email back to Mr. Zillgitt:
After reading your article, Blowing the whistle on shoddy NCAA officiating, I would like to offer you an invitation.
Go to you local officials association, go through their classes, take the test, get certified, and do a season worth of games. Not just one or two. You could get a really difficult or easy game and that would skew your view. An entire season. Games that mean something. Not scrimmages. Real games. It can be kids games. Doesnt have to be high school.
Then write a follow-up. Youll find out that safety net called slow motion instant replay and the 10-20 seconds to think about it arent available.
Am I an official? Yes sir.
Do officials ever make mistakes? Yes.
Do they take pride in what they do? You bet.
Why? One reason is also the same as for the players playing. Theyre competitive. And there are plenty of officials would would love to do the top games.
The worst that could happen if you accepted my invitation would be that you would learn the rules of the game. Good luck.
|
Good points in your email. I would love to see him take you up on your challange.
The only thing I would say about your email is to be careful with grammatical or spelling errors. You have to remember that this is a writer and that he/she will be quicker to dismiss what you write if there are grammatical errors. My worst subject was English so I'm not the best to point these out but I did notice a few.
-
Go to your local officials association
-
Not just one or two. You could get a really difficult or easy game and that would skew your view. An entire season. Games that mean something. Not scrimmages. Real games. It can be kids games. Doesnt have to be high school. This could be condensed into a couple of sentences.
-
And there are plenty of officials who would love to do the top games.
Again, I am an analytical person so I'm probably not the best person to critique someones writing. He will pick apart problems with your writing the same way that we pick apart his lack of knowledge & experience when it comes to officiating.
I know that I'm knit picking but I just thought I'd help give him less ammunition.