View Single Post
  #1 (permalink)  
Old Tue Nov 25, 2003, 08:53am
zebracz zebracz is offline
Official Forum Member
 
Join Date: Nov 2003
Posts: 93
Send a message via Yahoo to zebracz
Question

Ok, I've got a hypothetical situation: W/ 3man mech. and you as trail, you do not see basket interference by a player who grabs the ball (what looked like/what you judged to be) not above, but away from, the cylinder and dunks it--a ball which had just bounced off the rim as a missed try.

You're sure you have 'a-best' look at it, so you pass, but your partner, the C, calls (offensive) BI -- His judgment, of course, was that the ball was indeed above the cylinder and even though it was prob'ly going to go in, the rebounder/team A player should have let the ball fall. Prob'ly 'fine' judgment, right? I mean, that's what he has seen...

Now, in this scenario, what's the best way to handle it?

a. If you know for sure that it was safe and that the angle you had showed the ball was not above, but away from the cylinder. Good dunk and points. ...or

b. If you're not sure and passed, but you think your partner may be in error. ...or

c. If just the original opposite? You call it but your partner knows for sure that it was a clean rebound and dunk. Do you want him/her to tell you? Correct it? Or would you rather he stay off?

I also would like some discussion on who's call it is and when? thx...
__________________
"Have you ever heard of the 5-pt play--a multiple foul on a 3-pt try that goes?" LoL
Reply With Quote