As a coach, I am not sure, even after having re-read the rule book, what the correct call is, so I thought I would pose this question on this board.
1. A has 2 and 10 from B 30.
2. A throws interception to B.
3. B returns the ball to B 23 then fumbles.
4. A recovers.
5. Officials mark the ball ready to play in A possession, but as a 3rd and 3. Rationale provided: down begins with A in possession, down ends with A in possession, line to gain was not acheived, therefore, no new series awarded.
But as I reviewed the Rule book, it seems to me that rule 5-1-3-d specifically applies:
"The team in possession at the end of the down, if there is a change of team possession during the down, unless the penalty is accepted for a foul which occurred before the change of possession."
There were no penalties on the play. It seems very clear to me that a new series should have been awarded...first and 10 for A at the B 23.
As it turned out, this particular call did not cost us the game...but it could have.
Any thoughts on the correct call?
|