Quote:
Originally Posted by BillyMac
I agree with you 99.9% that ruling (a) is "wrong".
But technically, ruling (a) isn't "wrong". The (a) ruling states that situation (a) is "illegal", which it most certainly is.
If ruling (a) is "wrong", it's "wrong" because, in combination with ruling (b), ruling (a) is confusing, misleading, incomplete, and ambiguous, but it's not "wrong" because situation (a) is indeed "illegal"
Thank God the caseplay has been changed.
|
IT WAS WRONG!!!!
Situation (a) included the words "and, in (b)", meaning the punishment for (b) is different than the punishment for (a).
If you are going to be anal, then be completely anal.