Quote:
Originally Posted by BillyMac
I did reply to their reply with a followup question regarding the "Interpretation" thread from a few days ago (what happens to old interpretations no longer in the casebook, or annual interpretations that never make their way into the casebook). I specifically asked about the vanished "player on the floor" casebook interpretation, and the "estimated time" one-and-done annual interpretation, but I also asked about vanishing/disappearing interpretations in general. I'll let everyone know if and when I get a reply.
|
Quote:
Originally Posted by BillyMac
Still waiting for IAABO's reply to vanishing/disappearing interpretations.
|
From IAABO Co-Coordinators of Interpreters:
We’ve certainly discussed the points you bring.
We (co-coordinators) all believe that it’s fair & reasonable to share your questions and concerns with the NFHS, to 1) get an answer and 2) possibly spur action on cataloging all interpretations, electronically for longevity sake.
Personally, pending different guidance from the NFHS, I feel, like you, that past interpretations are still in effect even if they’re not in the “current” casebook, unless replaced or changed. And as you noted, that makes the teaching of a rule dependent on 1) someone’s historical knowledge and 2) someone else “believing” that historical knowledge!
Thanks for your keen rules knowledge and historical perspective!
At their suggestion, I've forwarded my "old interpretation" concerns to Theresia D. Wynns, Editor, NFHS Publications, National Federation of State High School Associations:
Ms. Wynns,
IAABO Co-Coordinators of Interpreters suggested that I forward this email to you regarding questions about old interpretations and annual interpretations because you would be in the best position to accurately answer them.
Are old interpretations (casebook or annual), not in the current NFHS casebook, still fully valid as long as newer relevant rule changes and/or newer relevant interpretations haven’t invalidated such old interpretations?
Shouldn’t deleted interpretations be announced in some manner, possibly announced with a rationale for the deletion?
I included some specific examples, the "player on the floor" casebook interpretation, and the "estimated time" one-and-done annual interpretation.
I'll let everyone know if and when I get a reply.