Quote:
Originally Posted by teebob21
12U league play; Class C.
R1 on 3B only; 2 outs; bottom of 7th. BR hits a base hit to CF, runs to and through 1B. F8 misses the cutoff by F4 by a mile and the ball trickles to the infield. BR sees the overthrow, and while still past 1B, alters her path by a step or two as though she will advance to second. She does not advance, and starts walking back to 1B. The ball is fielded by F1 outside the circle, and thrown to F3 who applies the tag while BR is still walking back to 1B in fair territory.
The umpires rule score the run, and 3 outs. Game over. Coach claims she never made an attempt to advance; umpire judgment says otherwise.
Would you guys have ruled an out there as well? (And no, despite what the home parents thought, I did not just "want to get out of there.")  |
Besides what Rich bolded, there is a second one ---- umpire judgment.
At the instant she altered her path, your brain or nervous system or just feet reacted/prepared to cover 2nd even if no visible movement.
Reads like an out. My only hesitation would be about class C.