Quote:
Originally Posted by JRutledge
Can you direct me to the exact place where I can find this so-called definition? Because the actual definition of "judgment" does not suggest what you are saying.
All judgment means in a dictionary definitions, "the ability to make considered decisions or come to sensible conclusions."
So let us not add to what we say the word means when there is no such change in the definition.
|
Recognizing facts is not judgement. It has been used in basketball for a long time with a particular meaning whether you understand that or not. Judgement calls are calls that, when seen, the official has choices to make on whether there is something to call and if it should be called. Judgement calls are adjudicating the grey areas.
A player standing OOB with the ball is a fact. If it isn't called, it isn't due to judgement, it is not recognizing a fact, not seeing it.
This play was also a fact. The player clearly was dribbling, clearly picked the ball up with two hands, and clearly dribbled again. Those are the facts and no one with a brain can honestly say otherwise. There was no judgement needed here. He just missed it.
When a player has a hand on an opponent, you can call a foul or you can not call a foul...that is a judgment call.