Quote:
Originally Posted by bob jenkins
Here is an interp from 2002. I don't recall whether it ever made it to the case book:
SITUATION 6: At the pre-game conference, the home team coach is covering ground rules. He points out that in right field the light pole is a few feet in front of the fence. He mentions that a black tape is around the light pole, about 12 feet above the ground. He states that it is a home run if a fly ball hits the light pole above the tape since the ball would have easily cleared the fence if the light pole were not there. RULING: A ground rule cannot supersede the rules book. A fly ball hitting the light pole above the tape will remain in play and will not be ruled a home run. The batted fair ball must go over a fence in flight before a home run can be awarded. (4-1-2, 8-3-3a)
|
This is, in my mind, a poor ruling. No reason a ground rule shouldn't be able to deal with a pole in the field -- things like this are the whole reason for ground rules. I get why a lot of umpires just let teams do whatever they agree to in situations like this.