Quote:
Originally Posted by ilyazhito
I would support making all personal fouls, except those enforced between series, 15 and an automatic first down if committed by B. This will deter teams from committing personal fouls inside the 30 yard line.
|
Only for the team on defense there.
Why not break this down by type of personal foul and play situation, and then see if you think it needs additional deterrence?
Some personal fouls are roughing, which entail certain types of late hits (or otherwise illegal hits) while the ball is live. Other types are unnecessary roughness, some of which are late hits after the ball is dead, and others of which are other types; most commonly seen by the defense are those that involve tackling at or above the neck. Many of these are not tactical sorts of fouls. Some of these are as likely to be committed by players on offense as on defense, and others are not.
Any time you have an AFD, the severity of the penalty varies according to the down the foul occurred on and the distance to go.