Quote:
Originally Posted by SC Official
In some places officials who use those signals can't overcome the powers-that-be who only want "approved" signals.
|
Yes, from the little I know about college signals, they can be better than high school signals in describing what really happened.
And if the only thing going on was to get the game officiated properly (as if the game were officiated in a bubble), it wouldn't really matter what mechanics and signals one used, as long as the officials are in good position to make the calls, that the calls are correct, and the calls are communicated correctly to players, partner, coaches, table, and fans.
The reason why my local IAABO board wants only high school mechanics and signals is that IAABO is primarily a
basketball officiating educational organization. The education of new official doesn't end when they pass the rules and mechanics tests.
For learning purposes, we require subvarsity officials to stay and observe the varsity officials in the varsity game. The better, and quicker, they learn the proper mechanics and signals, the quicker they will move up in the ranks (of course, mechanics and signals aren't the end all, they also have to demonstrate other things, rules knowledge, game management, advantage/disadvantage, hustle, etc.). They are rated by observers, and one portion of the rating is on their mechanics (
"Utilizes proper mechanics, up-to-date techniques and procedures as detailed in the IAABO Officials Manual." ). New officials observing a varsity game can become confused if an official, especially a highly rated official, uses college mechanics and signals (or even worse, college rules) in a high school game.
Learning is easier, and probably better, if these young'uns see
consistent mechanics and signals, from one high school game to the next high school game, and from one high school official to the next high school official. It also helps a lot if what these young'uns see is the same as what's in the written IAABO mechanics manual (which is what they studied), as well as the same as what they've been taught in the mechanics classes.
Consistency is the key, deviations from one accepted way (even if not the best way) to do things can be misleading, and confusing, to learners.
I know a lot about learning, I've got thirty-plus years of award winning middle school teaching under my belt.