Quote:
Originally Posted by BillyMac
I never said that I don't use parameters outside the definition (proximity of the ball to the inbounder, time that the ball is available, etc.), to practically deem, or practically judge, disposal (after a goal).
Like you, I have to because the NFHS definition is so unbelievably poor.
But by the rulebook definition alone, determining disposal after a goal is an exercise in circular reasoning.
To dispute my last statement please show me a rulebook citation that includes parameters such as proximity of the ball to the inbounder, time that the ball is available, etc., in determining disposal after a goal.
Such citations don't exist, but you're welcome to try. Citation please.
Sometimes we just have to officiate. That's why we get paid the big bucks. Damn the rules. Damn the definitions. Full speed ahead.
|
You are allergic to the word "judgment". The rule says "available and the referee begins his count". That means somebody has to judge when it's available. Last I checked judgement belongs to officials, not players and not coaches.
The officials who make the really really big bucks are the ones who learned how to use their judgement in a common sense way when something is not spelled out explicitly in the rulebook.
Sent from my SM-N920P using Tapatalk