[ajmc]

Originally Posted by FormerUmp

T.J. Watt barrels down on Brett Hundley for key sack - NFL Videos

Should this have been penalized? The typically fan reaction is yes, but that doesn't necessarily mean anything. The quarterback wasn't defenseless in the typical sense, unless he's considered defenseless by rule in this situation.

Seeking some clarification.

If you want to debate the definition (much less the understanding) of the word defenseless KNOCK YOURSELF OUT (but you might find a willing tree stump first). The NFL, as well as other levels of football recognize and accept all "helmet contact" as both inevitable and problematic and want to minimize it as much as possible.

When Illegal Helmet Contact fouls (Spearing, Butt-Block, Face Tackle) were initiated, a seriously considered alternative of "removing facemasks" was a possibility if the Contact Fouls proved ineffective.

Up to that point, dangerous techniques were acceptable AND BEING TAUGHT AND ENCOURAGED and it was decided needed to be STOPPED.

At the interscholastic level, for the express purpose "to minimize risk" the "pop-up" free kick was deemed illegal (in the hope it will cease being taught).

Creating and subsequently expanding the definition of "Defenseless Player" is simply the latest step in minimizing helmet contacts, it may not be the last.